In the early hours of February 1, 2026, something unsettling happened outside 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie’s home in the Catalina Foothills. At 1:47 a.m., her doorbell camera feed abruptly went dark. Minutes later, motion was detected, but no video was saved. By 2:28 a.m., her pacemaker stopped syncing with her phone — a small but significant digital clue investigators now believe marks the moment she was moved out of range. When deputies later discovered blood on the porch, a back door open, and security cameras damaged, it became clear this was no ordinary disappearance. Newly recovered footage now shows an armed, masked individual at her front door — and authorities believe someone may recognize them.
According to federal officials, the suspect approached wearing dark clothing, gloves, and a ski mask, carrying a backpack and what appeared to be a firearm in a holster at the front of their waist. The footage, recovered after days of technical work with backend system data, shows the individual deliberately covering the camera and using nearby potted plants to block its view. Investigators described the movements as methodical but not flawless, suggesting planning mixed with improvisation. The timeframe between the camera disconnection and the pacemaker’s signal loss — roughly 17 minutes — has become central to the case timeline.
Nancy, a retired teacher and longtime member of her community, was last seen the evening before at her daughter’s home. She returned safely around 9:48 p.m., according to security footage. By Sunday morning, when she failed to attend her usual church livestream and calls went unanswered, family members grew concerned. Law enforcement quickly responded. Her phone and medication were left behind, heightening urgency due to her medical needs. In the days that followed, ransom emails demanding cryptocurrency surfaced, though officials have not confirmed the authenticity of those messages. Several hoax communications have already resulted in arrests unrelated to the primary investigation.
On February 10, the FBI released still images and brief clips of the masked individual, urging the public to examine details such as posture, gait, clothing fit, and the style of backpack and holster. Tips have since increased, and search efforts continue across nearby areas with assistance from federal agents, drones, and K-9 units. Authorities have not named a suspect but stress the case remains active. Nancy’s family has publicly appealed for information, emphasizing hope and asking anyone with credible details to contact law enforcement. Investigators believe that even the smallest observation — a familiar walk, clothing item, or unusual behavior — could make the difference in bringing answers to this case.